Re: [PATCH v11 00/10] Read/Write with meta/integrity

[Anuj gupta <anuj1072538@gmail.com>]

> > Testing has been done by modifying fio:
> > https://github.com/SamsungDS/fio/tree/priv/feat/pi-test-v11
>
> It looks like this never got into upstream fio.  Do you plan to submit
> it?  It would also be extremely useful to have a testing using it in
> blktests, because it seems like we don't have any test coverage for the
> read/write with metadata code at the moment.
>
> Just bringing this up because I want to be able to properly test the
> metadata side of the nvme/block support for the new DMA mapping API
> and I'm ѕtruggling to come up with good test coverage.
>

Hi Christoph,

The fio plumbing I had done for testing was pretty hacky (e.g., using
NVMe ioctls directly to query PI capabilities), so I didn’t send it
upstream. I plan to submit a liburing test. While working on it, I
realized that writing generic userspace tests is tricky without a way to
query the device’s integrity capabilities. The current sysfs interface
is limited — it doesn't expose key fields like pi_size or metadata_size,
which are necessary to correctly prepare protection information in
userspace.

That’s what motivated the ioctl RFC I sent earlier — to make it feasible
for userspace to construct metadata buffers correctly. Once it gets
settled, I can write some tests using it. Do you see this differently?